Should I buy a used Nintendo DSi XL or a new retro handheld?

Choosing between a used Nintendo DSi XL and a new retro handheld mostly comes down to what you care about most: the original DS experience or broader emulation in a newer device.

Buy a Nintendo DSi XL if:

• You mainly want to play Nintendo DS games. Its dual-screen, touchscreen layout is the best fit for DS titles, especially games that use the stylus or the two-screen setup.
• You want the original hardware experience. Physical buttons and native DS compatibility make it the most authentic way to play DS games.
• You’re okay with buying used hardware. Condition matters more than with a new device.

Buy a modern retro handheld if:

• You want one device for multiple systems. Many can emulate NES, SNES, Genesis, PlayStation 1, and sometimes more.
• You want modern conveniences like save states, fast-forward, and often a brighter higher-resolution screen.
• You want new hardware with less risk of battery wear, worn buttons, or screen damage.

Short recommendation:

• Pick the DSi XL if your main goal is DS games.
• Pick a retro handheld if you want broader emulation and a new device.

If you buy a DSi XL, check the screens, hinges, buttons, and battery health before buying, since used units can vary a lot. If you’re comparing specific retro handheld models, their features and charging standards can vary by model, so it’s worth checking the exact device before buying.