Should I buy a used Mazda CX-9 Signature or a Toyota Highlander XLE?

Choosing between a used Mazda CX-9 Signature and a Toyota Highlander XLE mostly comes down to driving feel vs. family practicality.

Buy the Mazda CX-9 Signature if:

• You want a more upscale, near-luxury cabin and more engaging handling.
• The third row will be for occasional use only.
• You prefer a crossover that feels a bit sportier and more refined.

Buy the Toyota Highlander XLE if:

• You need the more practical family hauler.
• You want better fuel economy: the Highlander is about 21 mpg city / 28 mpg highway versus the CX-9’s 20 mpg city / 26 mpg highway.
• You value easier ownership and stronger resale.

My lean

• Pick the Highlander XLE if you want the safer all-around used buy for most families.
• Pick the CX-9 Signature if you care more about interior feel and driving enjoyment and can live with the tighter third row and cargo area.

Because you’re buying used, check the service history, accident history, tires, brakes, and whether all scheduled maintenance was kept up.