Should I buy a used Honda Pilot or Toyota Highlander?

Choosing between a used Honda Pilot and a used Toyota Highlander mostly comes down to what you value more: space or fuel economy.

• Choose a used Honda Pilot if you want more cargo room, a roomier and more usable third row, and better interior storage.
• Choose a used Toyota Highlander if you want better fuel economy, especially if you’re looking at a Highlander Hybrid, and prefer a more car-like feel with comfortable front seats.

As a general rule, both are strong used buys and are similar in ride comfort and noise isolation. The Pilot tends to be the better family hauler if space matters most, while the Highlander is often the better choice if efficiency is a priority.

One caveat: used prices vary a lot by year, mileage, condition, and trim, and a Highlander Hybrid can cost noticeably more on the used market, so the fuel-savings payoff depends on how much more you pay up front. Also, specific powertrains and model years can have their own quirks, so it’s worth checking the exact year and trim you’re considering.