Which is better for city driving: a used Honda Fit or Toyota Yaris?

For most city drivers, a used Honda Fit is the superior choice. Its legendary "Magic Slide" rear seats and tall, boxy design offer unmatched cargo versatility, allowing you to haul bulky items that would never fit in other subcompacts. Furthermore, the Fit features exceptionally large windows and thin pillars, providing outstanding outward visibility that makes parallel parking and navigating tight urban traffic much easier.

However, the Toyota Yaris is the better pick if your absolute priority is minimizing ownership costs. It tends to have slightly lower long-term maintenance costs and, in some model years, slightly better real-world fuel economy. Note that US-market Yaris models from 2016 onward are actually rebadged Mazda 2s, which offer a more premium cabin and sportier ride but sacrifice cargo space compared to older Toyota-built versions.