Should I buy the Ninja Foodi Grill XL or George Foreman Grill?

The choice between the Ninja Foodi Grill XL and a George Foreman Grill mostly comes down to versatility vs. simplicity and price.

• Choose the Ninja Foodi Grill XL if you want an indoor grill that does more than grill. It’s a better pick if you want one appliance for grilling plus other cooking options, and you’re okay paying more for that flexibility.
• Choose a George Foreman Grill if you want a simple, compact, budget-friendly grill for quick meals. It’s a good fit for burgers, chicken, and sandwiches when you want something easy to use and store.

A practical rule of thumb: Ninja = more features and flexibility; George Foreman = simpler and usually cheaper. If you’re mostly making quick everyday grill-style meals, the George Foreman is usually the easier buy. If you want the indoor-grill version of an all-in-one cooker, go Ninja.

Exact features and pricing can vary by specific model and retailer, so it’s worth checking the current product listings before buying.